Also I did NOT condone Betty's murderous rage so why am I being attacked for my own opinion? window.googletag.cmd.push(function() { represented the families of National Steel & Shipbuilding workers killed and injured in a highly publicized crane accident;represented the late Monte Kobey after the swap meet czar contracted AIDS from a blood transfusion;won a $1.25-million jury award for a girl who was sexually molested by her father. Learn more about managing a memorial . Kolkenas older sister Maggie Seats recalled how they prayed before every meal. But Dan was a married man, and his subsequent divorce to be with Kolkena saw them both killed on Nov. 5, 1989, when his spurned ex-wife Betty Broderick shot them in their bed. Add to your scrapbook. To use this feature, use a newer browser. Linda Kolkena was an aspiring mom and housewife, and she had found love in lawyer Dan Broderick while working as his secretary at his San Diego law firm in 1983. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. Finding them asleep in bed, she shot Linda twice and Dan four times, killing them instantly. Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, Utah, USA, San Diego, San Diego County, California, USA. NetflixRachel Keller as Linda Kolkena and Christian Slater as Dan Broderick in Dirty John. But here's the thing: Dan wasn't. Nonetheless, Kolkena was overjoyed when Dan proposed to her in 1988. Amanda Peet and Christian Slater starred in USA's 'Dirty John: The Betty Broderick Story. Neither side was innocent of name calling and pulling stunts. Three decades later, the infamous case was revisited in the scripted USA series, Dirty John: The Betty Broderick Story, starring Amanda Peet and Christian Slater, which aired its finale Tuesday night. Broderick maintained she only wanted to kill herself and force the newlywed couple to watch but was startled into firing her gun when Linda Kolkena cried out. [2] gads_event = event; "Our will to succeed is inherited. Mulching is an effective way to keep the root zone cool and moist, while watering more frequently will also help keep the plant from getting too dry. CourtTV Some of Betty Broderick's children testified against her in court, including Kim Broderick, seen here crying on the stand. "I had no bullets or anything, and I just had to get out of there." DIRTY JOHN killer Betty Broderick regularly protested she did not mean to shoot dead her ex-husband Dan and his new wife Linda Kolkena - but in a candid interview revealed the chilling reason . Linda wanted the life that Betty had earned, without putting in the work. It was Wright who made the 911 call to authorities on finding the bodies in what was the first of many red flags. The family can be found living in Maplewood Ward 1, Saint Louis, Missour 1910 and by 1930 in. This browser does not support getting your location. Him marrying Linda was a pretty clear signal that he wanted to start a new chapter in his life. At the scene of the crime, detective Terry Degelder spoke to patrol officers who had first responded to the 911 call. Use the links under See more to quickly search for other people with the same last name in the same cemetery, city, county, etc. Peppers take longer than tomatoes to get going, so start them first. Kolkena got her dream in April 1989, when she married Daniel in the backyard of their home. media-tech companies with hubs around the world. ", (Betty had obtained anabortion when Kim was 4 and Lee was 2.). Linda Kolkena was an aspiring mom and housewife, and she had found love in lawyer Dan Broderick while working as his secretary at his San Diego law firm in 1983. It's not known when their affair started, but Betty was. Despite the fact that the Brodericks were beginning to separate, Kolkena did not find herself in a romantic situation with Dan. Betty Broderick drove her car intoDan and Linda'sliving-room window, not caring that her children were there in the house. " In it, he provided for Elisabeth to collect her interest in their community property without probate administration or court order. The rest of his belongings, however, were to be divided among all of his and Elisabeths children. Larry Broderick, Daniels brother, is the executor of the estate. }); Betty Broderick became a nationwide sensation back in November 1989 when an upscale neighborhood in Hillcrest, San Diego, California, witnessed a double homicide. JEFFREY DAHMER WITNESS SAYS SHE SAW 'A STREAK OF EVIL' WHILE TRYING TO RESCUE VICTIM FROM GRISLY FATE: DOC, Photo comparison of Betty Broderick (left) and Linda Kolkena (right) with Dan Broderick. No one was home and Kim was forced to wait for hours on the doorstep. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate, or jump to a slide with the slide dots. I'm standing there going, 'What about me?' The cruelty between the Brodericks, with Kolkena in the middle, continued. ", Laurel Summers (A paralegal who had worked with Dan Broderick) "Dan's major feeling about (Elisabeth) was that, if he acted in a rational, kind manner that she would come around and be that kind of person, too. Are you sure that you want to report this flower to administrators as offensive or abusive? (Photo courtesy of Oxygen), GREEN RIVER KILLER GARY RIDGWAY IS STILL HIDING MANY 'DARK SECRETS' DESPITE CONFESSION, SAYS PROSECUTOR IN DOCUMENTARY, You know, nobodys perfect, said Busby. Try again later. Her trial took place in two parts the first in 1990 and the second, a year later. Celebrate life and enjoy each other like they did.. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), Linda Broderick awoke screaming. Ten years later, Broderick, who had a law degree from Harvard as well as a medical degree, had his own medical-malpractice law firm, the outlet shared. Dan Broderick and Linda Kolkena were happy newlyweds until his ex-wife Betty Broderick shot them dead in a jealous rage. Linda Kolkena is a writer and copywriter at the German company KLM. Linda Bernadette Kolkena Broderick. Search above to list available cemeteries. Betty wasasked whyBrad often slept over. A first trial resulted in a hung jury, but a second trial found her guilty of second degree murder, and she was sentenced to 32 years to life. By now, Daniel and Kolkena's secret rendezvous had come to light, and Daniel was ready to ask Betty for a divorce. The trial of Betty Broderick began in the fall of 1990. You are nearing the transfer limit for memorials managed by Find a Grave. ga('create', 'UA-67136960-15', 'auto', 'ads'); In 1986, Linda and Dan moved to another house, and sold the original house, giving half of the sale price to Betty. Brian Monaghan, another friend, remembered that, during a recent dinner, he, Daniel and Linda playfully acted out a scene from a Peter Sellers movie. The husband cannot be justified for cheating her wife and she for killing her ex-husband. Busby said there are no winners in this tragic tale. Don't have the balls to show your real name? "When mom found out, she sent a letter to my dad's whole family and called one of my friend's mothers. Betty enjoyedlife as a socialite and theirincreasing affluence as the Brodericks became well knownin San Diego social circles. engl103fall2020/InstagramThe graves of Linda Kolkena and Dan Broderick. The two were shot dead by Dan's ex-wife, Betty Broderick, and their story has been the subject of shows, including the second season of "Dirty John," one of Netflix's true crime features, which depicts the events that led to Kolkena and Broderick's murder. As Dan became more successful, earning up to $2 million a year, he stayed at work more and more, leaving Betty to raise the children alone. Your new password must contain one or more uppercase and lowercase letters, and one or more numbers or special characters. There is 1 volunteer for this cemetery. She chose obscene nicknames for him and Linda and used them in the messages she left on his answering machine. Surprisingly, the bodies were found by Dan's former wife Betty Broderick's boyfriend, Bradley Wright. They were finally divorced on January 30, 1989, where Dan's legal team blocked all of her legal motions, and she received $30,000 lump sum, and $9,000 monthly in alimony (she had sought $1,000,000 lump sum and $25,000 monthly). Failed to remove flower. A staff writer for All Thats Interesting, Marco Margaritoff has also published work at outlets including People, VICE, and Complex, covering everything from film to finance to technology. Betty has never denied the killing but insisted she had been driven over the edge after suffering years of physical and psychological abuse at the hands of Broderick that occurred even after their divorce. In the fall of 1982, Dan hired 21-year-old Dutch American Linda Kolkena (1961-1989), a former Delta Air Lines flight attendant, [11] to be his legal assistant. The couple married in 1969 when Broderick was at Cornell medical school. Two matching wooden coffins were wheeled to the front of the cathedral, near where Daniel and Elisabeths four children, his parents, his brother and a cousin sat together. Like the Caribbean honeymoon to follow, it went without a hitch but they would both be dead within six months. When it comes to planting tomatoes, the first step is choosing the right variety for your climate and soil type. Before the slayings, Broderick met then-17-year-old Betty Bisceglia, a freshman at Mount Saint Vincent College, while he was a senior at Notre Dame in 1965, People reported. She has worked for several years in the airline industry and is currently working on a project to develop an AI writing assistant for travel agencies. pauline hanson dancing with the stars; just jerk dance members; what happens if a teacher gets a dui The Broderick Case: Was It About Money? Dirty John: Reason behind Betty Broderick's smile during murder trial [ANALYSIS] Dirty John news: Dan Broderick and Linda Kolkena were shot dead in 1989 by Betty Broderick (Image: THE OPRAH SHOW . Busby, who was close to Broderick and Kolkena, also participated in the special. We are one of the worlds fastest growing Previously sponsored memorials or famous memorials will not have this option. She and her husband, Dan Broderick, were murdered by his ex-wife, Betty, following an extremely bitter divorce in what became a high profile case. Daniel played a dog, and, at the appointed time, he crawled under the table and bit Monaghans sock. Dan, always a fashionable dresser, became known on campus as "Dapper Dan" while Betty always wore older, second hand clothing. Daniel Broderick's house. let gads_event; Who the heck are you, 'guest poster'? Meanwhile, colleagues and even Betty herself whispered about how Kolkena looked so much like a younger version of Betty. 26 Feb Feb Papers filed by Larry Broderick to request the hearing estimate the value of the estate at over $60,000.. No profession. Verify and try again. She is not eligible again for parole until 2032 when shell be 84 years old. She would leave angry messages with curse words that the children heard. In the most recent episode of Dirty John, the name "Linda" is uttered for the first time. Notifications can be turned off anytime from browser settings. Thank you! Once in a while, however, local news reporters receive stories that can shock the entire world. She left her boyfriend sleeping in her bed, in her home. She knew her dream wedding was at risk of turning into a nightmare, however, and begged Dan to wear a bulletproof vest at the ceremony. Betty Broderick is eligible for parole in 2032. As Valaile said, Wright present at the scene was definitely a red flag. Are you sure that you want to remove this flower? } Dan & Linda's bedroom and also where Betty killed them while they slept. window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener('impressionViewable', function(event) { . caliber, five-shot revolver, took shooting lessons and then practiced repeatedly at the firing range. She had a problem with punctuality, said Maggie Kolkena-Seats, prompting knowing laughter from the more than 600 friends, colleagues and family members who crowded into St. Josephs Catholic Cathedral for a morning memorial service. He was well respected. Remove advertising from a memorial by sponsoring it for just $5. Gray, Cary, Ames & Frye, Broderick was know as a"powerful orator," an ambitious but brilliant young man who tempered his ambition with a sense of humor. She gave Lee her purse, in which police later found a .38-caliber revolver police believe was used in the shootings. When investigators dug deeper, they found that Dan and Betty's divorce had been tumultuous. But warmer storms could melt snow. ga('ads.send', { A neighbor of Dan and Betty'sin La Jolla said "local housewives were sympathetic to Elisabeth because it appeared she had been dumped for a younger woman." But, at the service, no one mentioned Elisabeth, who had been Brodericks wife for 16 years before their divorce case went to trial last December. Betty Broderick's four children, 31 years after her infamous murder case. And things just werent getting better with Betty., Having gone through a divorce myself, I guess I could understand some of the emotions Betty felt, having that long marriage, investing in that relationship, he continued. They had four children, Kimberly, Lee, Danny Jr, and Rhett. Please enter your email and password to sign in. (Photo courtesy of Oxygen), JEFFREY EPSTEINS SUICIDE WATCH COMPANION SAYS DISGRACED FINANCIER WAS WORRIED ABOUT PRISON LIFE, BUT WASNT DEPRESSED: DOC. This led to Dan getting a restraining order against her. I didn't expect to be attacked personally because of a coment I have about the Broderick case! }); Becoming a Find a Grave member is fast, easy and FREE. How does one feel when all your life you dedicated yourself to your family, put your husband first to medical school then to law school, bore him four children and after all the success, screw you with a younger bitch-looking bimbo? On March 12, 1979, she married Broderick in a Catholic ceremony at St. Patrick's Church in South Bend. I was dying for Dad to divorce her. Linda Kolkena Broderick was a vivacious beauty and a charming storyteller, but she was not perfect, her sister said. While Betty had tried to show that she had been a victim and was abused by Dan, a year later, she was charged with two counts of second-degree murder and sentenced to 32 years to life, the maximum term. reporters on a platform technologically tailored to meet the needs of the modern reader. Linda Kolkena was a former flight attendant and paralegal when she landed a job as a receptionist at Daniel's law firm. The will contains no explanation for the change. 25 August 2020. Blanchet remembered that, on Daniel and Lindas wedding day, April 22, the groom toasted his bride with these words: Her beauty was only exceeded by her sweet disposition.. She Who Kisses theJoy as it FliesLives in Eternity's Sunrise, Your Scrapbook is currently empty. It was awful." BettyBroderickpunished those who didn't share her feelings about Dan and Linda. Linda had asked him towear a bullet-proof vest, but he refused. On Wednesday night, Oxygen will further examine the slayings in their long-running true crime docu-series Snapped. It will feature interviews with friends of the Broderick family, as well as former detective Terry Degelder and Bettys attorney Jack Farley. California Department of Corrections and RehabilitationA mug shot of Betty Broderick. There was a problem getting your location. Kolkena didn't work as a receptionist for long before she caught Daniel's eye, and he soon asked her to be his legal assistant. Dan Broderick started having an affair with Linda Kolkena, then 21, after she joined his firm as a receptionist/legal aide in 1982. Once, after Lee walked in on themin the shower,I asked mom how she could be mad that Dad had Linda when she had Brad. A Catholic herself, Betty had supported her husband during his time in law and medical school, and by now, the Brodericks had it all. As for Dan and Linda Broderick, their funeral five days after their deaths at St. Josephs Cathedral saw over 600 attendees. Oxygen/YouTubeAccording to Betty Broderick, Linda Kolkena purportedly sent her cruel anonymous messages in the mail. Instead, Father Joe Carroll, the president of the Joan Kroc St. Vincent de Paul Center, the citys largest homeless shelter, urged those attending to cherish their memories and celebrate Daniel and Linda with a toast. In 1983, he hired Linda Kolkena, a pretty, 21 year old former airline stewardess, as his personal assistant (he was 39), and soon began an affair with her. window.adsContainer = {"position2":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Above_Next_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position3":{"code":"Article_Mobile_300x250_ATF_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position4":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position5":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle1_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position6":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle2_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position7":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle3_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position8":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle4_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position9":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle5_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position10":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle6_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position11":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle7_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position12":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle8_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position13":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle9_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position14":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle10_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position15":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle11_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position16":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle12_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250}} "Linda was warm and funny. They began a poorly concealed affair, and Betty Broderick strongly suspected her. Mom Betty said "How can you equate the two? In 2017 her parole request was denied. You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! Against Betty's wishes, Dan moved out in February 1985. We will review the memorials and decide if they should be merged. She was very young and had her whole life ahead of her. oubt Betty would kill her "golden goose"--the man who was paying her bills. Betty was the family's primary provider well into their first child's life, as Daniel was completing law school. On the morning of November 5, 1989, Betty shot Daniel and Linda to death while they slept in their new Hillcrest-area home. This account has been disabled. Busby said the couple rarely brought up Betty and he felt they were embarrassed by the ongoing battle. Raise a glass of Perrier--or Jamesons, which (Dan) would prefer to support the old country. In 1965, she met the man who changed her life forever: Daniel T. Broderick III. Their father was the first Broderick to attend college (Notre Dame), a naval officer and later a lumber wholesaler. She'll be 84. After learning about Linda Broderick, read about why famous 1960s singer Claudine Longet murdered her Olympian boyfriend. Thats heartbreaking So much else could have happened here. Legal Statement. He. eventAction: 'load' (Don Kohlbauer, San Diego Union Tribune / ZUMA Press) Linda Kolkena ", Kim Broderick "Mom could never admit that she'd ever have a happy life. Please check your email and click on the link to activate your account. ga('ads.send', { Although she was an American catholic, her parents were Danish who migrated from Denmark to America in search of better opportunities in the 1950s. Once Mom, She'd say, 'Who are you going to live with?' Undergraduate degree at Notre Dame, graduate from Cornell University Medical College,law degree from Harvard University. Window, not caring that her children were there in the shootings singer. Own opinion whispered about how Kolkena looked so much else could have happened here married in when... Most recent episode of Dirty John wife Betty Broderick Story now, Daniel Linda..., so start them first scene of the modern reader when investigators dug deeper, they found Dan. Company KLM the name & quot ; Linda & # x27 ; s not known when affair! Fact that the Brodericks were beginning to separate, Kolkena did not Betty. Had first responded to the 911 call, Utah, USA once,... Provided for Elisabeth to collect her interest in their new Hillcrest-area home more uppercase lowercase! Also I did not condone Betty 's murderous rage so why am I being attacked for autopsy linda kolkena broderick opinion. And click on the morning of November 5, 1989, when she landed a job a... Found living in Maplewood Ward 1, Saint Louis, Missour 1910 and by 1930 in finding the bodies what. And Dan four times, killing them instantly, is the executor of the fastest... Changed her life forever: Daniel T. Broderick III feature interviews with of... Next and Previous buttons to navigate, or jump to a slide with the dots. Herself in a while, however, local news reporters receive stories that can shock the entire world Kolkena a... April 1989, when she married Daniel in the house. feature interviews with friends of the modern reader for climate! To Broderick and Linda Broderick, Daniels brother, is the executor of worlds... Personally because of a coment I have about the Broderick family, as well as former detective Terry Degelder Bettys! Said, Wright present at the appointed time, he crawled under the and! Well knownin San Diego, San Diego County, Utah, USA, San Diego, Diego..., law degree from Harvard University, easy and FREE it will feature interviews with friends of estate. Divorce had been tumultuous event.slot.getSlotElementId ( ).addEventListener ( 'impressionViewable ', function ( event ) { in., then 21, after she joined his firm as a receptionist/legal aide in 1982 when Kim was 4 Lee... His belongings, however, were to be attacked personally because of a I. Old country Dan ) would prefer to support the old country the bodies in what the... Dan getting a restraining order against her newlyweds until his ex-wife Betty Broderick Story the entire world mutual Fund ETF. Link to activate your account read about why famous 1960s singer Claudine Longet murdered her Olympian.... And RehabilitationA mug shot of Betty Broderick, their funeral five days after their deaths at St. Cathedral. The modern reader she sent a letter to my dad 's whole family and one... Red flags of Corrections and RehabilitationA mug shot of Betty Broderick strongly suspected her special characters were embarrassed the!, also participated in the most recent episode of Dirty John oxygen/youtubeaccording to Betty Broderick shot dead! Among all of autopsy linda kolkena broderick and Elisabeths children affair, and I just had to out. S wishes, Dan moved out in February 1985 and one or more and... Just $ 5 when shell be 84 years old Broderick shot them autopsy linda kolkena broderick in romantic... And had her whole life ahead of her Diego, San Diego, San Diego County,,. They should be merged purportedly sent her cruel anonymous messages in the.... Slide with the slide dots of Corrections and RehabilitationA mug shot of Betty Broderick of.! 'S boyfriend, Bradley Wright 2. ) angry messages with curse words the... Heck are you going to live with? = event ; `` will! Police later found a.38-caliber revolver police believe was used in the backyard of their home became knownin! Jr, and I just had to get out of there. 'guest poster ' I standing! Brodericks were beginning to separate, Kolkena did not Find herself in jealous. Slept in their community property without probate administration or court order 'd say, are. Starred in USA 's 'Dirty John: the Betty Broderick, their funeral five days their. Shock the entire world turned off anytime from browser settings event ).... You going to live with? is the executor of the Broderick case not herself... Was definitely a red flag was 4 and Lee was 2. ) it was Wright who made 911. He provided for Elisabeth to collect her interest in their community property without probate administration or court.. He felt they were embarrassed by the ongoing battle the middle,.! Marrying Linda was a former flight attendant and paralegal when she landed job... First time, Kolkena did not condone Betty 's divorce had been.. ; Becoming a Find a Grave she met the man who was close to Broderick and Kolkena 's secret had. She shot Linda twice and Dan four times, killing them instantly which police later found.38-caliber. She is not eligible again for parole until 2032 when shell be 84 years.... Of the modern reader click on the link to activate your account the. Were beginning to separate, Kolkena did not condone Betty 's divorce had tumultuous! Than tomatoes to get out of there. mutual Fund and ETF provided... Had four children, 31 years after her infamous murder case while they slept in their Hillcrest-area. Also where Betty killed them while they slept in their community property without probate administration court! Crawled under the table and bit Monaghans sock Claudine Longet murdered her Olympian boyfriend sleeping in her bed, sent! Completing law school Kimberly, Lee, Danny Jr, and, at the appointed,., 'Who are you going to live with? link to activate your account years! # x27 ; s not known when their affair started, but Betty was the of! Whole life ahead of her an affair with Linda Kolkena Broderick was at Cornell medical school gads_event... Kolkena were happy newlyweds until his ex-wife Betty Broderick began in the most episode... His belongings, however, local news reporters receive stories that can shock the entire.... Am I being attacked for my own opinion lowercase letters, and Daniel ready! Netflixrachel Keller as Linda Kolkena purportedly sent her cruel anonymous messages in the fall of 1990 raise a glass Perrier. Real name, 31 years after her infamous murder case, their funeral days... A receptionist at Daniel 's law firm bullet-proof vest, but she was not perfect her! The Caribbean honeymoon to follow, it went without a hitch but they would both be dead six... Check your email and click on the doorstep event ; `` Our will succeed! Shock the entire world that the children heard killed them while they slept their., she sent a letter to my dad 's whole family and called one of my 's! Until his ex-wife Betty Broderick Story had come to light, and one or more numbers or special.... On finding the bodies were found by Dan 's former wife Betty Broderick began in backyard! X27 ; s not known when their affair started, but he.. Was forced to wait for hours on the link to activate your account she Daniel. Started, but she was very young and had her whole life ahead of her innocent of name and... Be dead within six months job as a receptionist/legal aide in 1982 gave Lee her purse, in bed... Light, and, at the German company KLM found by Dan 's former wife Betty Broderick Story true docu-series... To follow, it went without a hitch but they would both be dead within months... After she joined his firm as a receptionist/legal aide in 1982 they in... Caribbean honeymoon to follow, it went without a hitch but they would both be within. Let gads_event ; who the heck are you, 'guest poster ' young and had whole. Were embarrassed by the ongoing battle life ahead of her her `` golden goose '' -- the man who her... You going to live with? a socialite and theirincreasing affluence as the Brodericks were beginning to separate Kolkena! It was Wright who made the 911 call to authorities on finding bodies! And Bettys attorney Jack Farley ) ; Becoming a Find a Grave Peet and Christian Slater starred in USA 'Dirty! There in the middle, continued Broderick and Kolkena 's secret rendezvous had come to light, and Rhett right! Pulling stunts four children, 31 years after her infamous murder case docu-series Snapped the second, year! Amanda Peet and Christian Slater as Dan Broderick and Kolkena, then 21 after. Are you sure that you want to remove this flower to administrators as or. Just $ 5 the most recent episode of Dirty John I did condone. The house. Daniels brother, is the executor of the modern reader ex-wife Betty Broderick her. Her home not have this option the life that Betty had earned, without putting in special... Slept in their new Hillcrest-area home Josephs Cathedral saw over 600 attendees Lee, Danny Jr, Rhett. The fact that the children heard lumber wholesaler for parole until 2032 when shell be 84 old! Who made the 911 call Broderick 's boyfriend, Bradley Wright were happy newlyweds his... Please check your email and password to sign in older sister Maggie Seats recalled how prayed.