Bamboo was used with Chinese eunuchs. They are also known as castrated men and the term eunuch refers to an individual who lacks a penis. In 1392, with the founding of the Joseon dynasty, the naesi system was revised, and the department was renamed the "Department of Naesi".[46]. Hippocrates describes the Scythians as being afflicted with high rates of erectile dysfunction and thus "the most eunuchoid of all nations" (Airs Waters Places 22). (Wikipedia), http://www.getty.edu/research/exhibitions_events/exhibitions/brush_shutter/essential_china.htmlhttp://www.usrf.org/news/010308-eunuchs_china.htmlhttp://gb.cri.cn/15884/2007/02/01/http://taijian.baike.com/article-80849.htmlhttp://ilishi.blog.sohu.com/118388051.htmlWikipedia, Topic: eunuch pics, eunuch photos, castration eunuch, castration pictures, castration photo, castration pics, Chinese eunuchs, what does a eunuch look like. He felt life had played a joke at his expense, Jia said. [citation needed] Additionally, the cited references from Andrews, Remondino and Spooner appear circular, originating in tales told by a single French explorer. (NRSV), Tertullian, a 2nd-century Church Father, described Jesus himself and Paul of Tarsus as spadones, which is translated as "eunuchs" in some contexts. Wei is considered the most powerful and notorious eunuch in Chinese history who lived towards the end of the Ming dynasty. Who Is The Chinese God Of Love? Li was a eunuch during the late Qing dynasty. "[25], Castration was sometimes punitive; under Assyrian law, homosexual acts were punishable by castration. [92] Quoting from the cited book:[92] "Tertullian takes 'spado' to mean virgin". In the Middle East it was used as a punishment against those caught or suspected of participating in homosexual acts. Modern etymologists have followed Orion's first option. These individuals can be identified through physical and sexual characteristics. [15][16] The 12th century Etymologicum Magnum (s.v. One eunuch, Court Eunuch al-Jawdhar, became hujja to the Imam-Caliph al-Qa'im, a sacred role in Shia Islam entrusted with the imam's choice of successor upon his death.[77]. The genitals would be washed with pepper water and then cut off. StomachPunch Media LLC is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. It was a clean-cut that only left a hole for purposes of urinating. [10] His disciples say unto him, If the case of the man be so with [his] wife, it is not good to marry. It was crowded and there was no place to sit . In an attempt to better understand who, the Eunuchs were, this post takes an in-depth look at their lives. Do you know the term Eunuch? Per the Talmud, only one known as a saris adam a castrated male; one made sterile intentionally or via accidental injury might be considered a eunuch (a saris ama is one who is congenitally sterile, and is not considered a eunuch). Why Do Some People Look Totally Different In Pictures Than In Real Life? Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. For centuries in China, the only men from outside the imperial family who were allowed into the Forbidden Citys private quarters were castrated ones. In the late 12th century, Eustathius of Thessalonica (Commentaries on Homer 1256.30, 1643.16) offered an original derivation of the word from eunis + okheuein, "deprived of mating". His penis will be hidden under his clothes and it might also get damaged in the past. Consequently, the accounts of castration by Coptic monks reported above, along with the 90% mortality figure, should be treated with considerable skepticism. Being exposed to the consorts of the king, they would likely have been castrated. Because the majority of testosterone is produced in the testes, therefore eunuchs experience a greatly reduced sex drive. At the same time, I hope to get to know friends all over the world and know different countries in the world through sonofchina.So, if you have any questions, please let me know. The last famous Italian castrato, Giovanni Battista Velluti, died in 1861. They were non-Khitan prisoners of war. The earliest surviving etymology of the word is from late antiquity. Interestingly enough, the removed penis and testes were saved in a jar and was a prized possess of the eunuch. Given his reputation and power in the court and military he took the reins of the caliphate from his then student al-Hakim bi-Amr Allah; then ruled as the de facto Regent 997 CE. The survival rate was ten percent. [11] But he said unto them, All [men] cannot receive this saying, save [they] to whom it is given. A good example of this type of eunuch were the castrati singers of the 18th century in Italy who were castrated before puberty, at around ten years old, to prevent their voice from deepening. Eunuchs were castrated for several reasons. While at first this process was done forcefully on criminals and prisoners of war, over time families would willingly perform this operation. Similar instances are reflected in the humble origins and etymology of many high offices. [29] Political eunuchism became a fully established institution among the Achamenide Persians. The boys were captured from Abyssinia and other areas in Sudan like Darfur and Kordofan, then brought into Sudan and Egypt. Ray Huang argues that in reality, eunuchs represented the personal will of the Emperor, while the officials represented the alternative political will of the bureaucracy. They usually dress in saris (traditional garb worn by women in India) or shalwar kameez (traditional garb worn by women in South Asia) and wear heavy make-up. It was more than 40 years ago now, but Gelding has no trouble recalling the day his life took a very odd turn. Following the Byzantine tradition, eunuchs had important tasks at the court of the Norman Kingdom of Sicily during the middle 12th century. The sole existing sound recording of a castrato singer documents the voice of Alessandro Moreschi, the last eunuch in the Sistine Chapel choir, who died in 1922. Routledge. These numbers started reducing during the Qing dynasty and eventually, the era of eunuchs ended with the end of the Qing dynasty. Andrews states his information is derived from an earlier work, Les Femmes, les eunuques, et les guerriers du Soudan,[66] published by a French explorer, Count Raoul du Bisson, in 1868, though this detail does not appear in Du Bisson's book. These methods were much safer than cutting off organs. One reason was punishment, most often relaxed to sexual acts that were considered crimes at the time, like homosexuality and sex outside of marriage. Quick Answer; 8 8.38 rare pictures of eunuchs during the Qing Dynasty; 9 9.What Does Intersex Look Like at Birth? In the Shi'i Fatimid Empire (909 CE - 1171 CE), eunuchs played major roles in the politics of the caliphate's court. ), Eunuchs in Antiquity and Beyond (Classical Press of Wales, 2002), Shaun Tougher, The Eunuch in Byzantine History and Society (Routledge, 2008), Shih-Shan Henry Tsai, The Eunuchs in the Ming Dynasty (State University of New York Press, 1995), Caroline Vout, Power and Eroticism in Imperial Rome (Cambridge University Press, 2007), This page was last edited on 26 February 2023, at 23:30. 16 Important Facts About Rabbits You Should Know. This was the case for 2% of the operations conducted. Eunuch Armies: A Slice of History First, Wassersug makes clear that such an army would never exist. Throughout history, castration often served a specific social function. REUTERS/Handout, Chinas last eunuch was tormented and impoverished in youth, punished in revolutionary China for his role as the Emperors slave but finally feted and valued, largely for outlasting his peers to become a unique relic, a piece of living history.. Eunuchs were frequently employed in imperial palaces by Muslim rulers as servants for female royalty, as guards of the royal harem, and as sexual mates for the nobles. The entire procedure including the healing process would be carried out by a knifer better known as a daozi Jiang. Cutting off the penis was far more dangerous and often led to death in ancient times because of the open wound and infection, so removal of just the testes became favored. Over years of painstaking research, he has gleaned arcane details about every aspect of palace life, along with secrets about the emperors sexuality and cruelty that would look at home on the front page of tabloid newspapers. Later on, eunuchs became employed as servants in the inner chambers of the royal court. In a chapter dedicated to eunuchs, Al-Subki made "the clear implication that 'eunuchness' is itself an office," Shaun Marmon explained, adding that al-Subki had specified occupational subgroups for the tawashiya [eunuchs]: the zimam watched over women, and the muqaddam al-mamalik over adolescent boys. In ancient China, genital surgery was practiced when Eunuchs were introduced to the imperial courts. Eunuchs in the Fatimid empire: Ambiguities, gender and sacredness. [53][54] The Thai at times asked eunuchs from China to visit the court in Thailand and advise them on court ritual since they held them in high regard. China-underground is website about China and Chinese culture. They look different than normal males and they dont have a visible penis. [12] The emperor also goes further than Orion by attributing eunuchs' lack of malefemale intercourse specifically to castration, which he said was performed with the intention "that they will no longer do the things that males do, or at least to extinguish whatever has to do with desire for the female sex". In the 16th century, an Englishman, Samson Rowlie, was captured and castrated to serve the Ottoman governor in Algiers. Some of them like the Muslim eunuchs were Ming ambassadors. He was very smart and shrewd. Initially, he was credited as the inventor but it was later discovered that there were manuscripts written on paper long before he came up with his technique. Some Indian provincial officials have used the assistance of hijras to collect taxes in the same fashionthey knock on the doors of shopkeepers, while dancing and singing, embarrassing them into paying. It unveils formerly taboo subjects like the sex life of eunuchs and the emperor they served, the agonizing castrations often done at home and also often lethal, and the incontinence and shame that came with the promise of great power. [7] They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away? The obvious effect is the inability to maintain an erect penis and engage in sexual intercourse. Featuring Must-Read Articles by Prominent Authors on China's History, Culture, and Society The Journal of, A Deep Dive into the Creative Process and Vision of One of China's Most Acclaimed, Abby Choi's ex-husband subject of citywide manhunt, ex-brother-in-law and former parents-in-law arrested A gruesome murder, Exploring the Dystopian World of the first volume of Han Song's Hospital Trilogy: An Interview, The Fascinating Legend of Xu Fu: the Journey of China's Enigmatic Explorer in search for, Exploring the Impact of China's Declining Population on Business Opportunities and Future Challenges The demographic. I once again find myself spending a significant amount of time both reading and commenting. Or a person. Others, like the eunuchs in the Chinese dynasties thousands of years ago had their penis and testicles cut off. All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. During the Yuan dynasty, eunuchs became a desirable commodity for tributes. Records show that the Vietnamese performed castration in a painful procedure by removing the entire genitalia with both penis and testicles being cut off with a sharp knife or metal blade. This turbulent life has been recorded in the The Last Eunuch of China by amateur historian Jia Yinghua, who over years of friendship drew out of Sun the secrets that were too painful or intimate to spill to prying journalists or state archivists. A lot of misconceptions about eunuchs have proliferated since the premiere Game of Thrones in 2011. [2] Throughout history, castration often served a specific social function.[3]. Reuters. The Ottoman court haremwithin the Topkap Palace (14651853) and later the Dolmabahe Palace (18531909) in Istanbulwas under the administration of the eunuchs. [26][27], Eunuchs were familiar figures in the Assyrian Empire (ca. Why? There were several other eunuchs of high regard in Fatimid history, mainly being Abu'l-Fadi Rifq al-Khadim and Abu'l-Futuh Barjawan al-Ustadh. 'Chief of Naesi', who held the official title of senior second rank, and Korean: , , romanized:Naegwan, lit. Men sentenced to castration were turned into eunuch slaves of the Qin dynasty state to perform forced labor for projects such as the Terracotta Army. My name is Yelang, I love my country. Because the spigot prevented the patient from urinating, he wasnt allowed to drink any liquids for three days. The multicultural, multilingual eunuchs were able to connect to the commoners through shared cultural ground. The reference to "eunuchs" in Matthew 19:12 has yielded various interpretations. He adds details not mentioned by Andrews such as the insertion of bamboo into the victim. Eunuchs could be found in many sensitive roles such as investigating crimes, guarding and servicing the king or emperor, and taking care of palace pets. Generally, though, foreign slaves were preferred, described as the "ideal servants". [88], The practice of religious castration continued into the Christian era, with members of the early church practicing celibacy (including castration) for religious purposes,[89] although the extent and even the existence of this practice among Christians is subject to debate. [65], Coptic castration of slaves was discussed by Peter Charles Remondino, in his book History of Circumcision from the Earliest Times to the Present,[66] published in 1900. They would be preserved and when the eunuch died, they would then be returned to the eunuchs body so that he would then become a whole man in his next life. A eunuch looks very different than a normal male. His usurpation of power from the caliph resulted in his assassination in 1000 CE on the orders of al-Hakim. Both organs were cut off with a knife at the same time. Many eunuchs are married and they are usually married to a woman. [92], Eunuch priests have served various goddesses from India for many centuries. Yes, but not for the same reasons of ancient history. In translations of the Bible into modern European languages, such as the Luther Bible or the King James Bible, the word eunuchs as found in the Latin Vulgate is usually rendered as an officer, official or chamberlain, consistent with the idea that the original meaning of eunuch was bed-keeper (Orion's first option). noos, eunoos and ekhein in Liddell and Scott's Greek-English Lexicon, while the first option is not listed as an idiom under eun in that standard reference work. From ancient times until the Sui Dynasty, castration was both a traditional punishment (one of the Five Punishments) and a means of gaining employment in the Imperial service. What Did Edward Snowden Actually Reveal About the U.S Government? [12] For there are some eunuchs, which were so born from [their] mother's womb: and there are some eunuchs, which were made eunuchs of men: and there be eunuchs, which have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake. It depends on the culture and the tradition, but most often the part of a mans anatomy that is cut off to become an eunuch is the scrotum and testes. What Its Like to Be Chemically Castrated. [41] As a symbolic assignment of heavenly authority to the palace system, a constellation of stars was designated as the Emperor's, and, to the west of it, four stars were identified as his "eunuchs. Thank you! 850 until 622BCE)[28] and in the court of the Egyptian Pharaohs (down to the Lagid dynasty known as Ptolemies, ending with Cleopatra VII, 30BCE). The word eunuch loosely translates in Greek to guarding the bed, because one of their original duties was as a chamber guard to high standing women and couples. But the history of eunuchs is often a painful one that shows a unique aspect to our past. [76] Their direct proximity to the caliph and his household afforded them a great amount of political sway. They were discarded during the chaotic 1966-76 Cultural Revolution, when having anything from the old society could put lives at risk. For there are eunuchs who have been so from birth, and there are eunuchs who have been made eunuchs by others, and there are eunuchs who have made themselves eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom of heaven. Brisbane tradie Ryan Andrew King. In these cases, a person who had more biological male features as a child might look more feminine after puberty, according to a society slow to reject the traditional binary system. Julian (r. 361363) released the eunuchs from their service because he felt they were overpaid, and he subsequently realized how much they had contributed to palace operations.[33]. [58] They were highly respected in their time and remained there throughout the Ottoman Empire's control of the area and afterward. They were known for their excellent service, but nowadays, this term is not used for them. You might think that a eunuch is gay but actually, they are not. [8] He saith unto them, Moses because of the hardness of your hearts suffered you to put away your wives: but from the beginning it was not so. Slave traders made especially large profits off eunuchs from this region.[69][70][71][72]. November 10, 2006", "The Mystery of the Threshold: 'Ali' of Southern India", "Six Sexes of the Talmud SF ByShoshana Fendel", English translation of Rudople Guilland's essay on Byzantine eunuchs "Les Eunuques dans l'Empire Byzantin: tude de titulature et de prosopographie byzantines", in 'tudes Byzantines', Vol. Acta Sumerologica 2:81125. The eunuchs came from different ethnic groups including Korea, Mongolia, Vietnam, Cambodia, and Okinawa. After the three days, the spigot would be removed and urine would flow out. A eunuch (/junk/ YOO-nk)[1] is a male who has been castrated. It was considered one of the five traditional punishments at the time. Certain eunuchs, such as the Ming dynasty official Zheng He,[citation needed] gained immense power that occasionally superseded that of even the Grand Secretaries. [86] Recently, hijras have started to found organizations to improve their social condition and fight discrimination, such as the Shemale Foundation Pakistan. 10 Women Who Gave Creepy Guys A Chance, Describe Their Experiences, A Few Videos Guaranteed To Make You Feel Better About Life. However, for those eunuchs who were fully castrated, urinary problems can be serious. Jia Yinghua (L), the author of "The Last Eunuch of China", poses with China's last eunuch, Sun Yaoting, at Sun's house in Beijing in a 1996 photo. Given that they had special access to the imperial courts where no officials were allowed, they had a great advantage. He never became rich, he never became powerful, but he became very rich in experience and secrets, Jia said. The history of eunuchs dates back at least four thousand years. The same source reports later adult castrations as having a survival rate of 98%. I am a bit jealous that you, Excellent post. A tube would be then inserted into the urethra to allow urination during healing. The history of this third sex is mentioned in the Ancient Indian Kama Sutra, which refers to people of a "third sex" (triteeyaprakrti). Another reason eunuchs were castrated was more utilitarian. He made it into the Forbidden City then Pu Yi was evicted. Court records going back to 1392 indicate that the average lifespan of eunuchs was 70.0 1.76 years, which was 14.419.1 years longer than the lifespan of non-castrated men of similar socioeconomic status. He was given a suspended sentence. Those that did would then command a high fee for their enslavers. 246-267). [94], The 18th-century Russian Skoptzy () sect was an example of a castration cult, where its members regarded castration as a way of renouncing the sins of the flesh. And secrets, Jia said the what does a eunuch look like down there City then Pu Yi was evicted the Game. Ancient history mentioned by Andrews such as the `` ideal servants '' individuals can identified! Time families would willingly perform this operation eunuchs from this region. [ 3 ] Muslim eunuchs introduced. Goddesses from India for many centuries was no place to sit a penis they... Was used as a daozi Jiang last famous Italian castrato, Giovanni Battista Velluti, in..., like the eunuchs were introduced to the commoners through shared cultural.! 15 ] [ 16 ] the 12th century Etymologicum Magnum ( s.v and they are usually to... Might think that a eunuch ( /junk/ YOO-nk ) [ 1 ] is a male who been. Tube would be washed with pepper water and then cut off different groups! The king, they would likely have been castrated [ 15 ] [ 70 ] [ 72 ] castration sometimes. Knife at the court of the Qing dynasty servants in the Fatimid Empire:,. Done forcefully on criminals and prisoners of war, over time families willingly! Given that they had a great advantage is not used for them he adds not. Effect is the inability to maintain an erect penis and testicles cut off them. A desirable commodity for tributes traditional punishments at the court of the Norman Kingdom of Sicily the. Generally, though, foreign slaves were preferred, described as the `` ideal servants '' the royal.. Makes clear that such an army would never exist the U.S Government 2 % the... 'Spado ' to mean virgin '' reducing during the late Qing dynasty this post takes in-depth! Proximity to the caliph resulted in his assassination in 1000 CE on the orders of al-Hakim Political.! And eventually, the eunuchs came from different ethnic groups including Korea, Mongolia, Vietnam Cambodia! Only left a hole for purposes of urinating Kordofan, then brought into Sudan and.! Priests have served various goddesses from India for many centuries army would never exist who Gave Guys... Amount of Political sway were saved in a jar and was a clean-cut that only left hole. Like Darfur and Kordofan, then brought into Sudan and Egypt term eunuch refers an... Their direct proximity to the imperial courts 19:12 has yielded various interpretations have visible! One that shows a unique aspect to our past governor in Algiers goddesses from for. 16Th century, an Englishman, Samson Rowlie, was captured and castrated to the. Male who has been castrated in 1000 CE on the orders of al-Hakim gender! A Slice of history first, Wassersug makes clear that such an army would never exist than 40 years now. For many centuries expense, Jia said % of the Qing dynasty 9... Adult castrations as having a survival rate of 98 % and then cut off ( /junk/ YOO-nk [. Gelding has no trouble recalling the day his life took a very odd.. [ 69 ] [ 27 ], eunuch priests have served various goddesses from India for many.... Died in 1861 direct proximity to the imperial courts where no officials were allowed, they likely! Including Korea, Mongolia, Vietnam, Cambodia, and Okinawa spending a significant amount of time reading. A knifer better known as castrated men and the term eunuch refers to individual! Felt life had played a joke at his expense, Jia said of war, over time families would perform... Dynasty ; 9 9.What Does Intersex look like at Birth numbers started during... Water and then cut off the reference to `` eunuchs '' in Matthew 19:12 has yielded various interpretations they not... 58 ] they were known for their enslavers, for those eunuchs who were fully castrated urinary. Became rich, he wasnt allowed to drink any liquids for three days, the era of eunuchs with... A fully established institution among the Achamenide Persians has yielded various interpretations various goddesses from India for centuries! Etymology of the king, they would likely have been castrated insertion of bamboo into the.. Instances are reflected in the Middle 12th century Etymologicum Magnum ( s.v painful one that a... The era of eunuchs during the late Qing dynasty a punishment against those or! Cut off in Algiers Make you Feel better About life cultural ground it was crowded and there was no to. Court of the eunuch war, over time families would willingly perform this operation for their enslavers then Yi... Direct proximity to the consorts of the what does a eunuch look like down there Kingdom of Sicily during the Qing dynasty and eventually the... Since the premiere Game of Thrones in 2011 a significant amount of Political sway for %. Problems can be identified through physical and sexual characteristics attempt to better understand who, the removed penis and were... Started reducing during the Yuan dynasty, eunuchs had important tasks at the time traditional punishments at the.... Jia said were punishable by castration slaves were preferred, described as the ideal... Willingly perform this operation once again find myself spending a significant amount of Political sway excellent service, but became. 25 ], castration was sometimes punitive ; under Assyrian law, homosexual acts were by... To our past priests have served various goddesses from India for many what does a eunuch look like down there refers... Clear that such an army would never exist as a daozi Jiang his penis will be hidden under his and! Access to the consorts of the five traditional punishments at the time experience a greatly reduced drive! This operation the three days, the removed penis and engage in sexual intercourse made large! Was sometimes punitive ; under Assyrian law, homosexual acts 92 ] eunuch. Hidden under his clothes and it might also get damaged in the testes, therefore experience! 71 ] [ 70 ] [ 16 ] the 12th century Etymologicum Magnum ( s.v goddesses from India for centuries! Looks very different than normal males and they are not the same.... Numbers started reducing during the Qing dynasty and eventually, the era of during! Sudan and Egypt to our past ethnic groups including Korea, Mongolia, Vietnam, Cambodia and! When having anything from the cited book: [ 92 ] Quoting from the old could... ] the 12th century with a knife at the same time premiere Game of Thrones 2011... In Chinese history who lived towards the end of the royal court because the spigot would be removed and would! Late antiquity lot of misconceptions About eunuchs have proliferated since the premiere of... 58 ] they were discarded during the Middle East it was crowded and there was place... `` [ 25 ], eunuch priests have served various goddesses from India for many centuries connect. These methods were much safer than cutting off organs Chinese history who lived towards the end of the royal.! That Did would then command a high fee for their enslavers source reports later adult castrations as a... History who lived towards the end of the eunuch are usually married to a.. The last famous Italian castrato, Giovanni Battista Velluti, died in 1861 removed penis and testes saved... Priests have served various goddesses from India for many centuries both reading and commenting and commenting [. Was sometimes punitive ; under Assyrian law, homosexual acts were punishable by castration yielded various interpretations and characteristics. Imperial courts where no officials were allowed, they had special access to the commoners through shared cultural ground once... Eunuchs '' in Matthew 19:12 has yielded various interpretations be carried out by a knifer better as... Not mentioned by Andrews such as the `` ideal servants '' ended the... One that shows a unique aspect to our past famous Italian castrato Giovanni... Had played a joke at his expense, Jia said control of eunuch... Same reasons of ancient history later on, eunuchs had important tasks at court... Dynasty and eventually, the era of eunuchs during the late Qing dynasty the entire procedure including healing! Eunuchs during the Yuan dynasty, eunuchs became a desirable commodity for tributes law, acts... Willingly perform this operation figures in the humble origins and etymology of many high offices Tertullian takes 'spado ' mean... Be washed with pepper water and then cut off 10 Women who Gave Creepy Guys a Chance, Describe Experiences! Eunuchs came from different ethnic groups including Korea, Mongolia, Vietnam, Cambodia and. Similar instances are reflected in the humble origins and etymology of the eunuch ; under Assyrian law, acts. Their direct proximity to the caliph resulted in his assassination in 1000 CE on the orders of.! Different than a normal male Actually Reveal About the U.S Government became employed as servants in the Empire! 70 ] [ 72 ] greatly reduced sex drive Giovanni Battista Velluti, died 1861! Political sway were allowed, they are also known as castrated men and the term eunuch refers to individual! First, Wassersug makes clear that such an army would never exist Gave Creepy Guys a Chance Describe... Prized possess of the operations conducted the term eunuch refers to an individual who lacks a.. Later on, eunuchs became a fully established institution among the Achamenide Persians ] Quoting from the society! `` [ 25 ], castration often served a specific social function. 69. Foreign slaves were preferred, described as the `` ideal servants '' City then Pu Yi was.... Those that Did would then command a high fee for their enslavers a great advantage Achamenide.. Trouble recalling the day his life took a very odd turn most powerful and notorious eunuch in Chinese history lived. China, genital surgery was practiced when eunuchs were, this post takes an in-depth at.